Introduction
Monensin is an ionophore produced by Streptomyces cinnamonensis. This agent has been used as coccidiostat and as antibiotic 7. In the last years, it has been incorporated as feed additive in order to improve performance in livestock production systems 10. Despite the widespread use of monensin, accidental intoxications in cattle 2, sheep 11, 12, horse 5, 15 and buffalo 18, 19 were reported in the literature. Monensin intoxication may occur due to mixing errors during feed preparation and its use in non-recommended species 14. The susceptibility to intoxication by monensin is variable and depends on each animal species. Horses are the most susceptible species to ionophore toxicity and fish, the most tolerant to exposure to high levels of ionophores 5, 8. Clinical signs depends on the amount of monensin ingested, and the predominant lesion is muscle degeneration 2, 16, 18. In the last years, the expansion of agriculture, along with the search for enhanced efficiency in livestock production has led to increased use of drugs, as strategies to improve profitability. In this context, antibiotics have contributed substantial improvement in the efficiency of intensive systems, which has led to an almost massive use over the last years 6. This paper describes a case of acute monensin poisoning in domestic buffalo (Bubalus bubalis), in a feedlot from north-eastern Argentina after accidental feeding. In addition to gross and microscopic lesions, clinical and epidemiological aspects of the disease have been identified.
Material and Methods
The case occurred in a small farm in the rural area of the town of Riachuelo, 18 km away from Corrientes city, in December 2017. The farm was visited to investigate an outbreak in buffaloes reported by its owner. The feedlot composed of 174 water buffalo calves of the Mediterranean breed with an average weight of 180 kg, received concentrated food and alfalfa ad-libitum. The farmer reported that some days before, concentrated food given to calves (without monensin), was changed by another commercial product, from another company, which lacked the corresponding product data-sheet. Within the first week of being fed with the new concentrate product, 15 of the animals showed reluctant to move and marked agitation. Within 10 days, 30 buffaloes became ill and died. The first measure taken was to suspend feeding with the concentrate product. Despite of, animals continued to die during ten days. The ill animals were clinically examined. Clinical signs were recorded and monensin intoxication was suspected. Blood samples were collected from 10 animals which seemed to be the most affected ones, to determine serum enzyme activities. Necropsy was performed in 5 animals. Heart, liver, lung, kidney, and skeletal and cardiac muscle were collected, fixed in 10% formalin for 24 h, processed for histology, stained with haematoxylin-eosin (HE) and examined by light microscopy. Three samples of the suspect feed were collected from three equally spaced points along the feeding system and a single aliquot was analyzed. The concentration of monensin was determined using an spectrophotometry method 4, and results were expressed in mg/kg.
Results
Mortality and lethality rates of the observed animals were 0.17 and 1.0, respectively, with 30 dead buffaloes being recorded. Clinical signs found ranged from anxiety facie with orthopneic position, diarrhea and teeth grinding, to muscular weakness and instability. Lastly, clinical signs progressed to severe depression and recumbency. The quantitative analysis of food samples revealed 65±6 mg/kg of sodium monensin in the total mix. Table 1 shows the biochemical parameters. Affected animals showed a significantly high values in aspartate aminotransferase and creatine phosphokinase activity (p<0.05), compare to healthy buffaloes (without clinical signs). Necropsy revealed that the cardiac and skeletal muscles of animals with clinical signs of intoxication had irregularly distributed pale areas, congestion and edema of the lung, along with hydrothorax (Figure 1). The main histological lesions were found in skeletal (Figure 2) and cardiac muscles (Figure 3); degenerative and necrotic changes were observed, with cytoplasmic hypereosinophilia, loss of striations and fragmentation of muscle fibers. All cases had focal mononuclear infiltration of varying degrees. In affected animals, the liver showed marked hepatocellular vacuolization, as well as centrilobular coagulative necrosis (Figure 4). The lungs showed congestion, and alveolar and interstitial oedema. Presence of cylindrical and hyaline content was observed in Bowman’s space and in the renal tubule. The remaining tissues showed no histological changes.
Discussion
Diagnosis of experimental and accidental monensin toxicosis is based on clinical signs, pathological lesions and biochemical changes of serum parameters 8, 18-21. In this study, the presence of monensin was evidenced in food samples using a simple and effective spectrophotometric method for ionophore quantitative measurement. In cattle, the use of monensin is authorised for fattening, up to a concentration of 50 mg/kg feed 19. In this work, the amount of monensin was determined in feed samples. This result shows the importance of monitoring nutrients and aggregates of chemical composition in the food offered to these animals. The toxic dose of monensin for buffaloes has been reported to be 5 mg/kg 18 and the LD50 for cattle was estimated within a range of 21.9 up to 80 mg/kg 2, 16, demonstrating the susceptibility of buffaloes to monensin. In our study, the key to confirm the diagnosis was to measure the monensin level in feed samples. In Argentina, reported outbreaks occurred in cattle 4, 17 and buffaloes 3 in Buenos Aires. However, the concentration of monensin in food was not determined. An important proportion (17%) of the animals showed muscular weakness due to extensive muscle damage. Clinically, all the signs described agree with the reported natural and experimental cases of ruminant intoxicated by monensin 3, 8, 18-21. Elevation of serum CPK and AST activities indicated progressive structural muscle damage in affected buffaloes. The elevation of these enzymes in serum has been reported in accidental intoxications with monensin and other ionophore compounds 1, 8, 9, 13, 19, 21. Histopathological studies of the myocardium and skeletal muscle revealed severe degeneration and necrosis. These lesions can explain the disorders in animal attitude and locomotor disorders of affected animals. These lesions were described in sheep 11, 12, goat 8, buffalo 3 and cattle poisoned with monensin 19. In conclusion, this study reaffirms the poisoning by monensin in buffaloes in Argentina, based on clinical signs, enzymogram, pathological lesions and monensin levels in the food. Although the positive effect of monensin has been generally reported as a good additive in food for the performance of the animals, the use of monensin for feeding buffaloes should be made with great caution.