Resumo

NASCIMENTO, Daniel Simão. On the Normative Consequences of Virtue and Utility Friendships in Aristotle. Rev. latinoam. filos. [online]. 2017, vol.43, n.2, pp.263-284. ISSN 1852-7353.

In this article, I use the expanded hohfeldian model presented by Wenar to argue that, according to Aristotle's theory of friendship, every bond of friendship that is based on utility or virtue creates duties and hohfeldian incidents between those who are friends. In section 1, I provide a quick presentation of Hohfeld's work and of Wenar's hohfeldian model. In section 2, I present my thesis about the creation of certain hohfeldian incidents and certain duties in virtue and utility friendships as conceived by Aristotle. In section 3, I give a broad characterization of Aristotle's theory of friendship and of the three great kinds of friendship that he recognizes. In section 4, I defend the thesis that it is only in virtue and utility friendships that duties are created. In section 5, I specify what are the hohfeldian incidents created by these two kinds of friendship. In section 6, I specify the two ways in which, according to Aristotle, these incidents and duties might be created. In section 7, I conclude with a brief recapitulation of the argument.

Palavras-chave : Aristotle; Hohfeld; Friendship; Normativity; Duty.

        · resumo em Espanhol     · texto em Inglês     · Inglês ( pdf )